It seems particularly ironic to me that in the week of the closing of London's fantastically successful Olympics 2012, with all and sundry rightly praising the welcome and friendliness afforded by the Capital, our first game of the new season sends us to Loftus Rd., a reminder of what football used to be like in the 80's.
Despite its gentrifying and tartification, where the Club's hierarchy has explicitly tried to move it up-market with the cancerous phrases "boutique football" and "retro-chic" prevalent (with concomitant but unsurprising increases in cost of admission - £50 Cat A anyone??), this remains one of the most unpleasant of all PL Grounds to visit.
Here's a bit of advice to any fellow Jacks travelling - don't drink in the local pubs, wear spit-proof clothing if possible, get in = get out = get home.
That comes from at least 6 visits for me, and each and every time has been unpleasant, not just for the results, which were almost all uniformly bad for us, but from the experience. Anyway, having started you off by revealing my prejudices, I leave you to form your own impressions on Saturday, and let's hope the football matches a more pleasant experience.
QPR, our closely linked arrivistes from our most recent Championship season, did at least survive last year,(see final table here), but in a manner a degree less comfortable than for either ourselves or fellow first timers Norwich City, and their last day defeat to the Champs Man City left them relying on the eventual relegatees to do worse than they did. To their great relief, Wolves, Blackburn and Bolton did, and were.
Whilst we are rightly concerned with a progressive development of our modern stadium, any amount of layers of fresh paint can't disguise the fact that Loftus Rd, with its 18500 capacity remains the PL's smallest stadium, and an era of increasing reliability on Clubs to maximise their income, has led to their owner, the slightly more enlightened than previously Tony Fernandes, the Air Asia supremo, concentrating their efforts on relocating to a 35000-45000 alternative in the foreseeable future. Trust me, this is not easy anywhere. In West London, it's nigh on impossible (ask RA at Chelski), and the search goes on.
So with this off field churn and turmoil on going, what of the on field progression, or otherwise.
You will remember that despite his beneficent comments re their erstwhile Manager Colin Wanker (sic) toward the end of his tenure - ( "He's a special guy, we're very happy with him," Fernandes said then ) - it didn't stop an eight game non-winning run leading to Warnock's dismissal, and replacement with a familiar foe, the egregious (choose your adjective), Mark Hughes.
Whilst Hughes attempted to re-shape the team before the season's end, their last day survival owed more to the ineptitude of the three below.
However, we shouldn't belittle the ubiquitous Hughes, since he has a habit of producing teams after his own style - combative, technically proficient, tactically astute, hard grafting and dirty. Yes, I did say that, and I mean it. His teams would generally kick their Grandmother for a point. Often.
There is, indeed, evolution underfoot under Hughes' tenure, and, to be fair, it's of a rather higher order than previously, and the Jay Bothroyd/Junior Campbell type signings are making way for greater quality.
Using his Blackburn Rovers period and influence, two of the more intriguing signings were Ryan Nelsen, the veteran NZ CB acquired from a Tottenham release, and the exciting and young David (Junior) Hoilett,on a Free Agency from Blackburn.
Whilst Nelsen is long in the tooth, he brings experience, and Hoilett, as those of us who travelled to Ewood Park last year remember, turned us inside out on more than one occasion. Still, I like to think we've learned from then.
Furthermore, in goal,the error prone Paddy Kenny has gone, to be replaced by Rob Green, the England keeper from West Ham, although Green has had moments of his own.
The
observant will have noticed that whereas last season when Hughes came
in, the fees for Cisse and others were somewhat inflated, when we
contrast this year with the above, who were all free at Contracts end,
even the £2m paid for Park Ji Sung, Man Utd's still combative 31yr old
midfielder, and a player who SAF trusted, have not been overly
excessive.
Similarly from Man Utd., the lesser twin, Fabio de Silva, has come in on a full year's loan, with a view to buy. His brother Rafael's excesses in Brazil's defeat to Mexico in the Olympic Finals perhaps reinforced the perception that Fabio is the better of the twins, so The R's may have got lucky.
There remain, of course, the eternal problems relating to Twitter's very own Superstar and Renaissance man extant, Joseph Barton 7. Suspended for 12 games, specifically for a multiplicity of offences v Man City last season, and currently purportedly on loan to Fleetwood Town, in a crude attempt to shorten the suspension, this is an issue that will not just go away. It appears, however, that the FA have seen this for what it appeared to be - namely, an attempt to shorten JB's suspension period by getting him some games for a lesser but earlier performing club. To their credit, the Game's Trustees are not minded to let this go through.
More power to their elbow.
Most sensate adults would acquiesce if asked to give an offender a second chance. Lets be honest - most of us have probably nicked a Mars Bar from a sweetshop when young ( mea maxima culpa) .
But a 9th Chance?? Surely not, brother. Lest I be accused of trivialising the misdemeanors of JB, please remember they include beating a youth insensible outside a Liverpool McDonalds (classy-sic) (for which he was jailed) and assaulting a team-mate and breaking his jaw shortly after stabbing a youth player in the eye with a cigar.That's just part of his CV. 'Nuff said.
Good footballer though, eh? as I heard some very silly person on TalkSport say recently. You couldn't make it up, really.
All of the above parts will add to the remaining signings from last year, particularly Djibrill Cisse , Bobby Zamora, Samba Diakite and Nedum Onouha. All of those are decent players, so Hughes will believe that he can merge the older with the more newly acquired.
Add the impressive Alejandro Faurlin, the flighty Shaun Wright Phillips and some older warriors like Clint Hill and Shaun Derry. Then we get to that lesser controversial half of the Ferdinand brothers, Anton, (sic), along with Armand Traore, and the perennially-posturing Adel Taarabt, who still remains for me a sort of Christiano Ronaldo from the Blue Square.
Forgive me my insouciance, it's just that this is a club that winds me up. I don't know why (......well maybe), I do know how, but this over-inflated, bloated squad is going to contain a number of disaffected players who don't make the final mark. Subject to that cut, we'll see where we go from there. This, currently, is their squad listing, or the nearest to it that I could get.........
Goalkeepers
Murphy, Cerny, Green
Defenders
Nelsen, Onuoha, Traore, Hill, Connolly, Young, Ferdinand, Da Silva
Midfielders
Wright-Phillips, Barton, Taarabt, Ehmer, Ephraim, Faurlin, Diakite, ParkDerry
Forwards
Hulse,Campbell, Zamora, Mackie, Helguson, Cisse, Smith, Bothroyd, Balanta, Hoilett, Johnson
You will notice from my notes above that I haven't even mentioned the grafting forward Jamie Mackie, a sort of Bambi on stilts who retains an ability to score when he should fall over, or the headhunter Rob Hulse, who would give Jade Jones a bloody good fight. Some might question his footballing ability, but maybe on Saturday, we might get to see.
Whoops, I've forgotten the aggressive Tommy Smith, who continues to score goals against decent Clubs. Helgusson has gone to Cardiff, it seems. And then there's Andrew Johnson. Snaffled from Fulham again at Contracts end, he has still some pertinent ability, but seems to be a player who can be controlled, as we proved last year at both Craven Cottage and the Lib..
Then we get to players like Luke Young, the ex Villa FB, Peter Ramage, Danny Gabbidon, and Hogan Ephtraim is still on the books, a grafting MF'er. Add in Angelo Balanta, Bruno Andrade, and several others, and it will tell you that to get to a squad of 25 they have some crucial decisions. Still, we know how that feels.
So what of tactics, and the approach?
Similarly from Man Utd., the lesser twin, Fabio de Silva, has come in on a full year's loan, with a view to buy. His brother Rafael's excesses in Brazil's defeat to Mexico in the Olympic Finals perhaps reinforced the perception that Fabio is the better of the twins, so The R's may have got lucky.
There remain, of course, the eternal problems relating to Twitter's very own Superstar and Renaissance man extant, Joseph Barton 7. Suspended for 12 games, specifically for a multiplicity of offences v Man City last season, and currently purportedly on loan to Fleetwood Town, in a crude attempt to shorten the suspension, this is an issue that will not just go away. It appears, however, that the FA have seen this for what it appeared to be - namely, an attempt to shorten JB's suspension period by getting him some games for a lesser but earlier performing club. To their credit, the Game's Trustees are not minded to let this go through.
More power to their elbow.
Most sensate adults would acquiesce if asked to give an offender a second chance. Lets be honest - most of us have probably nicked a Mars Bar from a sweetshop when young ( mea maxima culpa) .
But a 9th Chance?? Surely not, brother. Lest I be accused of trivialising the misdemeanors of JB, please remember they include beating a youth insensible outside a Liverpool McDonalds (classy-sic) (for which he was jailed) and assaulting a team-mate and breaking his jaw shortly after stabbing a youth player in the eye with a cigar.That's just part of his CV. 'Nuff said.
Good footballer though, eh? as I heard some very silly person on TalkSport say recently. You couldn't make it up, really.
All of the above parts will add to the remaining signings from last year, particularly Djibrill Cisse , Bobby Zamora, Samba Diakite and Nedum Onouha. All of those are decent players, so Hughes will believe that he can merge the older with the more newly acquired.
Add the impressive Alejandro Faurlin, the flighty Shaun Wright Phillips and some older warriors like Clint Hill and Shaun Derry. Then we get to that lesser controversial half of the Ferdinand brothers, Anton, (sic), along with Armand Traore, and the perennially-posturing Adel Taarabt, who still remains for me a sort of Christiano Ronaldo from the Blue Square.
Forgive me my insouciance, it's just that this is a club that winds me up. I don't know why (......well maybe), I do know how, but this over-inflated, bloated squad is going to contain a number of disaffected players who don't make the final mark. Subject to that cut, we'll see where we go from there. This, currently, is their squad listing, or the nearest to it that I could get.........
Goalkeepers
Murphy, Cerny, Green
Defenders
Nelsen, Onuoha, Traore, Hill, Connolly, Young, Ferdinand, Da Silva
Midfielders
Wright-Phillips, Barton, Taarabt, Ehmer, Ephraim, Faurlin, Diakite, ParkDerry
Forwards
Hulse,Campbell, Zamora, Mackie, Helguson, Cisse, Smith, Bothroyd, Balanta, Hoilett, Johnson
You will notice from my notes above that I haven't even mentioned the grafting forward Jamie Mackie, a sort of Bambi on stilts who retains an ability to score when he should fall over, or the headhunter Rob Hulse, who would give Jade Jones a bloody good fight. Some might question his footballing ability, but maybe on Saturday, we might get to see.
Whoops, I've forgotten the aggressive Tommy Smith, who continues to score goals against decent Clubs. Helgusson has gone to Cardiff, it seems. And then there's Andrew Johnson. Snaffled from Fulham again at Contracts end, he has still some pertinent ability, but seems to be a player who can be controlled, as we proved last year at both Craven Cottage and the Lib..
Then we get to players like Luke Young, the ex Villa FB, Peter Ramage, Danny Gabbidon, and Hogan Ephtraim is still on the books, a grafting MF'er. Add in Angelo Balanta, Bruno Andrade, and several others, and it will tell you that to get to a squad of 25 they have some crucial decisions. Still, we know how that feels.
So what of tactics, and the approach?
Hughes'
teams generally operate to a 4-4-2 variant.There is a degree of
flexibility, but the ultimate sin is failing to graft. They will be
ferociously committed.
One of the advantages of a smaller, old stadium is that the crowd intensity becomes an influential factor. For all it's faults, Loftus Rd does at least tick this box. Expect rabid R's fans at the throat of our team throughout, with special dispensation given to "Sheep" songs. Gimme shelter. Just give them the finger, please.
Think back to Blackburn when Hughes was in charge and as I've said above, they always had their share of technical proficiency, but, above all, they were
One of the advantages of a smaller, old stadium is that the crowd intensity becomes an influential factor. For all it's faults, Loftus Rd does at least tick this box. Expect rabid R's fans at the throat of our team throughout, with special dispensation given to "Sheep" songs. Gimme shelter. Just give them the finger, please.
Think back to Blackburn when Hughes was in charge and as I've said above, they always had their share of technical proficiency, but, above all, they were
physical.
Arsene
Wenger has said on countless occasions that they always took the rules
to the limit - and we should expect no difference. Hughes will send his
side out to physically intimidate, just as he did personally, so it will
be key to be able to resist this.
From what we've seen of the Swans so far pre-season I find it hard to evaluate just where, exactly, we are.
In comparison to last year we know, of course, that we've lost Caulker, Sigurdsson and Allen. Good luck to Joe btw, he brought us a lot of pleasure, and in the ethos of the PL, undoubtedly the "greed is good" League, it was ever thus.
The immediate replacements seem sound, if that's what they are.
Chico Flores will be a hand on heart player who gives his all and I suspect he'll become a favourite.
Michu is the best deal we've done for a long time. I'll buy into a player who scored 15 La Liga goals last year in a struggling side. A sound character, too, who will give his all for our club.
I've seen a great deal of debate on Swans friendly websites recently on JdeG. I say one thing - chill, brothers. This is a hugely talented footballer who will take longer to settle in, and that's because he's a playmaker. So please, give him time, give him our support, and it'll help.
I'll reserve judgment on Itay Shechter, but any attacking support for DG is welcome.
We all know the quality the rest of the squad afforded us last season. After suffering another pilfering of our Manager, it was fantastic and ambitious to recruit the admirable Michael Laudrup.
I've read a lot about our nascent differences from last year, where we varied from an out and out 4-3-3 to a sophisticated 4-2-3-1, via the odd avenue of 4-1-4-1 along the way. Btw, no more 3-5-2 please ML, my heart won't stand it.
The very least we should expect is a subtle difference. Michael Laudrup is not Brendan Rodgers (thank goodness), so it was interesting to read his comments on his differing take on the role of our wide players.
From what we've seen of the Swans so far pre-season I find it hard to evaluate just where, exactly, we are.
In comparison to last year we know, of course, that we've lost Caulker, Sigurdsson and Allen. Good luck to Joe btw, he brought us a lot of pleasure, and in the ethos of the PL, undoubtedly the "greed is good" League, it was ever thus.
The immediate replacements seem sound, if that's what they are.
Chico Flores will be a hand on heart player who gives his all and I suspect he'll become a favourite.
Michu is the best deal we've done for a long time. I'll buy into a player who scored 15 La Liga goals last year in a struggling side. A sound character, too, who will give his all for our club.
I've seen a great deal of debate on Swans friendly websites recently on JdeG. I say one thing - chill, brothers. This is a hugely talented footballer who will take longer to settle in, and that's because he's a playmaker. So please, give him time, give him our support, and it'll help.
I'll reserve judgment on Itay Shechter, but any attacking support for DG is welcome.
We all know the quality the rest of the squad afforded us last season. After suffering another pilfering of our Manager, it was fantastic and ambitious to recruit the admirable Michael Laudrup.
I've read a lot about our nascent differences from last year, where we varied from an out and out 4-3-3 to a sophisticated 4-2-3-1, via the odd avenue of 4-1-4-1 along the way. Btw, no more 3-5-2 please ML, my heart won't stand it.
The very least we should expect is a subtle difference. Michael Laudrup is not Brendan Rodgers (thank goodness), so it was interesting to read his comments on his differing take on the role of our wide players.
Each
new Manager at our Club brings his own, and his staff's, influence.
Whilst it would be foolish to expect a carbon copy of our style, most of
us will hope that ML can develop and build upon what we've already
achieved. But, it will be different, and we should embrace that change in the fond hope that it makes us better still.
Don't forget that despite the loss of 3 gifted players, and their replacement by 3 who'll be their equal
(we hope), we still have many and varied talents within the Squad, not least the pass master, Leon Britton. Short people, eh?
Isn't it great to be talking about our second season in this hardest of Divisions? I think so.
Our job, as fans, is to support the efforts being made on our behalf, and to ENJOY!!
Am I nervous? Yes, intensely.
Am I worried? Not in the slightest, this is Football.
Am I expectant? You bet your life I am.
Start me up.
Onward, Swansea City.
##
And in further news , perhaps JB7 would like to spend some time in the sun, but I'd recommend not getting into any fights down South.They take things rather seriously in France's largest port.
Our job, as fans, is to support the efforts being made on our behalf, and to ENJOY!!
Am I nervous? Yes, intensely.
Am I worried? Not in the slightest, this is Football.
Am I expectant? You bet your life I am.
Start me up.
Onward, Swansea City.
##
And in further news , perhaps JB7 would like to spend some time in the sun, but I'd recommend not getting into any fights down South.They take things rather seriously in France's largest port.
15 comments:
Great post - mpressed - how they could use you at the SWEP !
What a lame attempt at a hatchet job!
Your prejudices seem to have dulled your senses.
As I'm sure you know, "boutique football" was the phrase used by the previous owners - the odious Flavio Briatore, loathed by the fans, who celebrated when he left.
Strange that you ridicule "boutique", but look down your nose at our "unpleasant" ground.
Why waste 5 paragraphs on Joey Barton? He will not play, is unlikely to be named in the 25 man squad and may never play for QPR again.
In contrast, only a fleeting mention for Adel Taarabt - I wonder why?
You say Taarabt is "perennially-posturing" and "a sort of Christiano Ronaldo from the Blue Square".
Funnily enough, Taarabt loves playing Swansea, because he destroys you every time.
11.4.2011 QPR 3 Swansea 0 [2 assists by Taarabt]
26.12.2010 QPR 4 Swansea 0 [Assist for the 1st, won the penalty for the 2nd, scored the 3rd and 4th himself].
I hope he does a bit more posturing for you on Saturday.
You say the fee for Cissé was "somewhat inflated". Really?
He cost approx £3M. He was an absolute steal. I would argue he is one of the top 5 strikers in the PL. He played in 8 games for us, got sent off in 2, and scored in every other game [6 in 6]. He will score a hatful this season.
Paddy Kenny is "error prone". OK. Played for QPR v Swansea in 4 games, conceded 1 goal [Graham handballed to control the ball].
"Jamie Mackie, a sort of Bambi on stilts who retains an ability to score when he should fall over" - too true, played 4 games against Swansea, scored in 3 of them.
You make great play of the size of the squad, but 12 players have left this summer, including some you list as remaining, and many more are peripheral and set to leave.
Swansea are a well-run club, but I think you'll struggle to do as well as last year.
I think QPR can only improve.
Roll on Saturday!
..Thank you for your spirited reply, have a good season, just not as good as ours.:)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Df1zdsceihc&feature=player_embedded
Very poor preview.Cant really add to what BQPR said,but I will use visual aides.
Commentary is in Arabic but for you who dont remember or if your neutral and havent seen the vid its of Adel Taarabt making a complete fool of Swansea's little midfield maestro Joe Allen.He nutmegs him (yes that embarressing move loved in playgrounds all over the world)and goes on to score a beauty.Allen refused to come within 10 yards of Adel after that.
Fair play to you boys mugging off Liverpool for him.Nice bit of buisiness that.Adel must be worth 35 mil...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Df1zdsceihc&feature=player_embedded
You Swansea bunch are very snobby when it comes to stadiums considering not so long ago you were at the Vetch (which was a decrepit dive) and also the Liberty is the second smallest stadium in the prem and was fully funded by the council for you!
The comments above have already pointed out your various inaccuracies - but i still hope you have a better match experience if not a better result anyway...
Thanks for advising your fellow Swansea supporters to get swiftly in and out of our part of West London. That would be my preferred option too. That said, like most visiting provincial clubs, I'll wager that a good percentage of your "travelling" support will be people who left behind the poor employment prospects of their home town to come to London as economic migrants.
Loftus Road is what it is I'm afraid, cramp, uncomfortable and too small for the premiership but for most Rs it'll be a home greatly missed when (if)we get the new ground. I preferred the Vetch to the Liberty to be honest but then I'm from a time when you could instantly recognise each ground on the TV, now they all look the same. I'm sorry you've had such a consistenntly god awful time at the Bush, and experiences do darken your view of a club. I got lamped at Burnley in 1974/5 and I have hated that inoffensive club with a passion since. You're very wrong about Taarabt though, whatever his faults, they've never been on display against Swansea against whom I am afraid to say he makes you look like right chumps. I think Rs will be all right this season, though I fear our style of play will win few friends. Swansea I suspect will find it tougher. It would be good for the prem to have 2 Welsh clubs but the fear must be that you'll swap with your real bete noireup the road
God I love you Jacks, always the snob, never the humble
Wasted your breath a bit on Barton, though agree you'd do well to get in and out of w12 quickly (and quietly)
Roll on Saturday, Adel is waiting for you.....
Haha Jesus Christ. And you promote this review by saying "I'm back" ...?! This was by far the worst and most inaccurate review I've ever read. I mean, if you're gonna spend that much time writing, and actually trying to get something out of if - for gods sake, at least get the facts right will you? And since the majority of the comments come from QPR fans I believe you did a pretty shitty job. Throw the laptop away and I back to football manager... and dream.
I mean, after all you're still Swansea...
Read your blog regularly, but I am afraid this one falls below your usual high standards (perhaps due to your unhappy experiences at Loftus Road). In your desire to get your revenge in early and point out our many weaknesses, you haven't provided your readers with any sense of our strengths (other than the Stoke-like qualities of 'graft' & 'commitment'). Some of them may therefore have difficulty understanding the QPR team that they see in front of their eyes at Loftus Road. We do actually have a lot of skillful players (just ask Joe Allen about being left for dead by Taarabt). If anything our problem last season was our lack of muscle against some of the more physical sides (not to mention players getting sent off left, right and centre).
My thoughts on some of the individuals you singled out from our glorious team:
Barton - I absolutely hate the guy & his Nietzschean bullshit. Was never, ever captain material and has now become an utter liability.
Hughes - Whatever his past transgressions he doesn't seem to have brought in any dirty tactics this time around. His 4-4-2 didn't work that well with the players we had, so was pretty much abandonned at the end of last season. We'll see if it comes back.
Paddy Kenny - Never that error prone, but was injured throughout last season. Part of the meanest defence in all four divisions the season before last. Trying to keep an open mind about his replacement.
Jamie Mackie - After a broken leg last year his goal away at Man City proved that you just can't keep a good man down.
Adel Taarabt - You might not like him, but he sure luuurves you.
Swansea
Well, you've got the man you wanted. Laudrup strikes me as an imaginative appointment, and intelligent enough not to try and change things too much or too quickly. He knows the Spanish league and has made some decent buys (didn't Sid Lowe say Michu was the bargain of the summmer?).
There seems to be a consensus among QPR fans that Swansea will struggle with second season syndrome (which miraculously won't affect us), but I think you will be OK.
Btw, I was hoping you'd comment on the Joe Allen sale in the light of Liverpool's commitment not to buy any Swansea player for a year. I'd be pretty pissed off with Rodgers if I was you.
....thanks again for the comments.
@Tactical QPR = re the Joe Allen sale, it didn't surprise me that BR came back in and I suspect that the reported £15m release clause was known to him and it was his way of circumventing the "hands off" agreement.
Of course, £15m will help toward a replacement and also contribute toward Academy/Training Grond development which is ongoing in conjunction with Stadium enhancement scheduled to start at Season's end.
All will be helped by our maintaining a presence in this division. Never a quiet moment, eh>
We are also getting a decent training ground at Warren Farm after years of lacking the most basic elements of club infrastructure.
Btw, talking of 'what football used to be like in the 80's', I lived in Swansea in the early 80s so got to see James, Charles, Waddle & co in the old Second Division.
Looks like we're deporting Barton to Marseille. I can only see that ending in a diplomatic incident, and possibly war with France.
@TacticalQPR
...those 80's days with Curt/Robbie etc were indeed pleasant, I enjoyed them too.
Good luck with the Warren Farm project - that's the way Clubs like ours both develop. On the same route from our end, Llandarcy (Academy) and Fairwood ( first team in conjunction with Swansea University) are both up and running.
I wish you well, too, in your search for a landspace in W.London - that MUST be difficult.
Anyway, here's to good game. Respect.
Blimey. Bit sensitive, aren't they? Have you deleted all their comments from 5pm on 18th onwards- there don't seem to be any ;-)
...don't worry, Match Report will be up in the next day or so. I wonder if they'll have the bottle to come back. We'll see.
Post a Comment